Skip to content

Errata in ITU-R BS.468

This is the entry of the errata registry on ITU-R BS.468-4. The registry’s introduction says how each claim is checked against the printed page and what the status of an entry means.

ITU-R BS.468-4, Table 2, 5 ms upper limit (the dB cell should read −6.7)

Section titled “ITU-R BS.468-4, Table 2, 5 ms upper limit (the dB cell should read −6.7)”
  • Location: clause 2.1, Table 2, “Limiting values — upper limit”, the 5 ms column (printed p. 4). The same pair of cells is printed identically in IEC 60268-1:1985 Table AII and in the Amendment 1:1988 table that replaces it, so the defect is inherited from the CCIR text rather than introduced by either edition.
  • The print: 46 in the (%) row and −6.6 in the (dB) row.
  • The problem: the two disagree. 46 % is 20 lg(0.46) = −6.745 dB, and −6.6 dB is 46.8 %. All 33 cells of Tables 2 and 3 were audited against their own counterpart; 32 agree to within 0.050 dB, the rounding of a two-significant-figure percentage, and this one is out by 0.145 dB. The neighbouring 5 ms lower limit (34, −9.3) is out by 0.070 dB and is benign, because 34 % as a rounded two-figure percentage covers 33.5 % to 34.5 %, that is −9.500 dB to −9.241 dB, and −9.3 lies inside it. The upper cell is not benign: 46 % covers 45.5 % to 46.5 %, that is −6.840 dB to −6.651 dB, which excludes −6.6.
  • Which cell is wrong: the dB one. Read as percentages, the acceptance window is a very steady −1.4 dB / +1.2 dB about the reference reading for every duration from 5 ms to 200 ms (+1.18 to +1.24 dB above, −1.37 to −1.45 dB below). 46 % puts the 5 ms upper limit +1.214 dB above its reference, on that pattern; 46.774 %, which is what −6.6 dB means, would put it +1.360 dB above, off it. So 46 % is right and the dB cell should read −6.7.
  • Evidence: 20 lg of each printed percentage compared with the printed dB cell beside it, for all 24 cells of Table 2 and all 9 of Table 3, and the upper- and lower-limit offsets about the reference row recomputed across the five durations from 5 ms to 200 ms. Verified on PDF page 4 (printed p. 4) of Recommendation ITU-R BS.468-4, on PDF page 33 (printed p. 31) of IEC 60268-1:1985, and on PDF page 3 (printed p. 3) of IEC 60268-1:1985 Amendment 1:1988.
  • Library behaviour: the percentage rows are primary and the dB rows are derived from them, which is the decision this entry forces. The eleven acceptance windows are stored as percentages in tests/reference_data/ and checked as percentages, in the test suite and in the conformance rows “ITU-R BS.468-4 Table 2” and “ITU-R BS.468-4 Table 3”.
  • Status: unreported.