Skip to content

Errata in ISO/TR 17534

These are the 2 entries of the errata registry on ISO/TR 17534-3:2015, in the order the registry lists them. The registry’s introduction says how each claim is checked against the printed page and what the status of an entry means.

ISO/TR 17534-3:2015, Table 20 (q credited to the wrong footnote of ISO 9613-2 Table 3)

Section titled “ISO/TR 17534-3:2015, Table 20 (q credited to the wrong footnote of ISO 9613-2 Table 3)”
  • Location: Table 20, “Single number step by step results” of test case T08, the row naming the middle-region overlap factor .
  • The print: q (ISO 9613-2:1996, Table 3, footnote 1).
  • The problem: footnote 1 of ISO 9613-2:1996, Table 3 is about which ground factor and which height each outer region takes (“For calculating , take and …”). It says nothing about . The factor is defined by footnote 2 of the same table, which is where the guideline itself sends the reader in the four other places it prints the row: Table 3 (T01), Table 8 (T04), Table 14 (T06) and Table 22 (T09) all read “Table 3 footnote 2”. Table 20 is the single occurrence that reads footnote 1, and the value it carries, , is the one footnote 2 produces.
  • Evidence: the row was read on PDF page 23 (printed p. 17) of ISO/TR 17534-3:2015, and the four consistent occurrences of the same row on PDF pages 13, 16, 20 and 41 (printed pp. 7, 10, 14 and 35) of the same edition; the two footnotes it points at were read on PDF page 10 (printed p. 8) of ISO 9613-2:1996.
  • Library behaviour: unaffected. The typographical slip is in a cross-reference, not in a number, and ground_attenuation implements from footnote 2, which is what reproduces the printed 0.23.
  • Status: unreported.

ISO/TR 17534-3:2015, Table 69 (the worked TRC form answers “yes” for a result below its lower limit)

Section titled “ISO/TR 17534-3:2015, Table 69 (the worked TRC form answers “yes” for a result below its lower limit)”
  • Location: Table 69, “Example of a TRC-form based on test case 1”, the row of test case T01 at 250 Hz.
  • The print: upper limit 31,15, lower limit 31,05, software calculation result (exemplary) 31,0, and “yes” in the column “Result inside tolerances”.
  • The problem: 31.0 dB lies 0.05 dB below the lower limit 31.05 dB, so the row answers “yes” for a result outside its interval. The interval itself is right: Table 4, the spectral step-by-step results of T01, certifies dB at 250 Hz, and 31.05 to 31.15 is that result ±0.05 dB. Every other row of the form carries its certified result to one decimal, and each of them is inside: seven rounded, among them 13.70 as 13.7, 23.76 as 23.8 and the total 44.29 as 44.3, and the 1 000 Hz row cut down, 38.95 printed as 38.9 on its lower limit of 38.90, where rounding gives 39.0. Rounded or cut, 31.10 to one decimal is 31.1, and the exemplary result was most likely meant to read 31.1.
  • Evidence: read on PDF page 59 (printed p. 53) of ISO/TR 17534-3:2015, first edition, with Table 4 on PDF page 14 (printed p. 8) of the same edition.
  • Library behaviour: unaffected, since the library never reads Table 69. Given the nine rows of the form, verify_calculation_results answers “no” for the 250 Hz row alone, which test_table_69_of_iso_tr_17534_3_fails_only_at_250_hz pins.
  • Status: unreported.
Edit page

Published , updated