Errata in ISO 12999
These are the 3 entries of the errata registry on ISO 12999-1:2020 and ISO 12999-2:2020, in the order the registry lists them. The registry’s introduction says how each claim is checked against the printed page and what the status of an entry means.
ISO 12999-1:2020, Table 4 (missing 500 Hz row)
Section titled “ISO 12999-1:2020, Table 4 (missing 500 Hz row)”- Location: Table 4 (in-situ uncertainties per band).
- The print: the 2020 edition’s table omits the 500 Hz row that the 2014 edition prints (situation B 1,2 dB / situation C 0,8 dB).
- The problem: likely an editorial omission; the surrounding rows are unchanged between editions and the text does not mention removing the band.
- Evidence: side-by-side comparison of the 2014 and 2020 prints.
- Library behaviour: follows the 2020 print as published, with the omission documented in the module.
- Status: unreported.
ISO 12999-2:2020, Clause 8 wording vs Tables 4 and 5
Section titled “ISO 12999-2:2020, Clause 8 wording vs Tables 4 and 5”- Location: Clause 8 “Reporting uncertainties” (printed pp. 5-6), the where-list under Formula (10), against the worked Tables 4 and 5 (printed p. 7). An earlier revision of this entry called the clause “expression of results”, which is not its printed title.
- The print: the where-list defines as “the standard uncertainty determined in accordance with Clause 5, Clause 6 or Clause 7 rounded to two decimal digits for absorption coefficients or one decimal digit for all other quantities”, and Formula (10) then forms .
- The problem: the document’s own Tables 4 and 5 only reproduce when is computed from the unrounded and rounded last. Neither table prints a column at all (each has only the coefficient or and with ), so the printed values are the whole of the evidence, and 11 of the 25 are unreachable under the literal clause wording.
- Evidence: recomputation of all 25 entries (Table 4: 20 rows, Table 5: 5 rows) from Formula (1) with the Table 1 constants and from Formula (4) with the Table 2 constants, under both conventions. Round-last reproduces 25 of 25; round-first misses 11 of 25 (63, 125, 160, 200, 250, 1250, 1600, 2000, 3150 and 4000 Hz of Table 4, and 250 Hz of Table 5). An earlier revision of this entry quoted the count as “10 of 20”, which is neither the right numerator nor the right number of entries. Verified on PDF pages 9 (printed p. 3), 10 (printed p. 4), 11 (printed p. 5) and 13 (printed p. 7) of ISO 12999-2:2020.
- Library behaviour: rounds last, matching the tables; the convention is documented and tested.
- Status: unreported.
ISO 12999-2:2020, Table 5 (octave-band data under a one-third-octave header)
Section titled “ISO 12999-2:2020, Table 5 (octave-band data under a one-third-octave header)”- Location: clause 8, Table 5 “Example for the practical sound absorption coefficient, αp, and its expanded uncertainty under reproducibility conditions” (printed p. 7).
- The print: the frequency column of Table 5 is headed “One-third octave midband frequency / Hz” and its rows are 250, 500, 1 000, 2 000 and 4 000 Hz.
- The problem: those five frequencies are the octave-band series of ISO 11654, which is what the practical sound absorption coefficient is defined over; they are not a one-third-octave series, and no one-third octave band is missing between them. The document contradicts itself on the same quantity two pages earlier: Table 2, which supplies the and constants of Formula (4) for exactly these five frequencies, is headed “Octave midband frequency”. The same header text stands over Table 4 on the same page, where it is correct: that table carries a genuine one-third-octave series, 63 Hz to 5 000 Hz in 20 rows.
- Evidence: the five tabulated frequencies themselves, and the “Octave midband frequency” header of Table 2 for the same constants. Verified on PDF page 13 (printed p. 7) and PDF page 11 (printed p. 5) of ISO 12999-2:2020.
- Library behaviour:
_TABLE2inuncertainty.pyis keyed by octave midband frequency, following Table 2 and the ISO 11654 definition of rather than the Table 5 header. - Status: unreported.
Created and maintained by José Manuel Requena PlensORCIDAbout the maintainerRelease notesChangelogAll projects