Errata in ISO 11820
This is the entry of the errata registry on ISO 11820:1996. The registry’s introduction says how each claim is checked against the printed page and what the status of an entry means.
ISO 11820:1996, Equations (20) and (22) (a temperature ratio the wrong way up)
Section titled “ISO 11820:1996, Equations (20) and (22) (a temperature ratio the wrong way up)”- Location: Equation (20) of 9.1.3 on printed page 11 (PDF page 19) and Equation (22) of 9.1.4 on printed page 12 (PDF page 20).
- The print: dB, with “the temperature, in degrees Celsius, on the receiver side” and “on the source side”; and, for the insertion loss, dB, with the temperature with the silencer and without it. The sentence under Equation (20) explains it: “The different temperatures determine different sound velocities which result in different conversion factors from squared sound pressure to sound power.”
- The problem: the ratio is inverted, and the sentence says why. The field correction is a conversion from squared sound pressure to sound power, and the standard fixes its sign on its own page: Equations (5) and (7) on printed page 3 add it, dB and dB , with subscript 1 the receiver side and subscript 2 the source side, the same assignment Equation (20) keys. So + const. The sentence counts only the change in , which rises as , and forgets that the density falls: the standard’s own Equation (29) on printed page 12 gives , so at one ambient pressure falls as and rises as . Hotter gas therefore needs the more positive correction, and the difference is , the reciprocal of the print. Both printed forms carry the same inversion, so this is the equation and not a misprinted subscript in one of them.
- Evidence: the three equations and the two keys read on the page. Equation (20) with its key and the explanatory sentence, and Equations (18) and (19), are on PDF page 19 (printed p. 11); Equations (5), (7) and their keys are on PDF page 11 (printed p. 3); Equation (22) with its key and Equation (29) with = 8 314.4 N·m/(kmol·K) are on PDF page 20 (printed p. 12). All of BS EN ISO 11820:1997, which prints EN ISO 11820:1996. A second ISO document prints the same quantity the other way up: the reference quantity correction of ISO 3741:2010, which its key calls “a function of the characteristic impedance of the air”, is dB dB, added to in Equation (20) on PDF page 31 (printed p. 22) of BS EN ISO 3741:2010, and it rises with temperature.
- Consequence for the standard’s own tables: ISO 11820 prints no worked example, so nothing in the document is wrong on its face. In use the sign costs twice the correction: with a receiver at 20 °C and a source at 200 °C the print gives -1.04 dB where the impedance gives +1.04 dB, so both the transmission loss of Equation (19) and the insertion loss of Equation (21) come out 2.08 dB low.
- Library behaviour:
temperature_field_correctionreturns the equation as printed, because a reader holding ISO 11820 has to find the standard’s own number, and its docstring names this entry. The conformance row “ISO 11820:1996 Eqs. (20) and (22)” pins the printed form. - Status: not reported.
Created and maintained by José Manuel Requena PlensORCIDAbout the maintainerRelease notesChangelogAll projects