Errata in ISO 10847
These are the 2 entries of the errata registry on ISO 10847:1997, in the order the registry lists them. The registry’s introduction says how each claim is checked against the printed page and what the status of an entry means.
ISO 10847:1997, Table 1 (an upwind class printed with a positive lower bound)
Section titled “ISO 10847:1997, Table 1 (an upwind class printed with a positive lower bound)”- Location: Table 1, “Class of wind conditions”, on printed page 6 (PDF page 10).
- The print: the short-distance block of the table lists three classes
against the vector component of the wind velocity in m/s: “Downwind + 1 to
- 5”, “Calm − 1 to + 1” and “Upwind + 1 to − 5”.
- The problem: ”+ 1 to − 5” is not an interval. Its two ends run the wrong way round, and its lower end is the value at which the downwind class two rows above begins, so read literally the upwind class would start inside the downwind one and reach backwards through calm. The sign of the lower bound is the character at fault: the upwind class is − 1 to − 5, the mirror of the downwind row, which is also what the word “upwind” means for a component that 6.3.1 defines as positive along the source-to-receiver line.
- Evidence: the three short-distance rows read together on printed page 6, against the all-distances block above them, which prints the same downwind and calm rows and no upwind one at all. Verified on PDF page 10 (printed p. 6) of ISO 10847:1997.
- Consequence for the standard’s own tables: none. No other clause computes with the interval.
- Library behaviour:
WIND_CLASSEScarries the upwind class as − 5 m/s to − 1 m/s andwind_classreturns it for negative components over a short distance alone, which is where the table prints it. - Status: not reported.
ISO 10847:1997, 8.2.2 (one prime asked to mean two different things)
Section titled “ISO 10847:1997, 8.2.2 (one prime asked to mean two different things)”- Location: the two level-difference equations of 8.2.2 and the list of symbols under them, on printed page 11 (PDF page 15).
- The print: and , and then ” and are correction factors for the type of receiver position; for “hemi free-field”: = 0 dB; for “on reflecting surfaces”: = 6 dB”.
- The problem: the prime carries two meanings in the same clause. In the equations it separates the “before” campaign from the “after” one, since every other symbol in them is subscripted B or A. In the definitions it separates one kind of receiver position from the other. Taken literally the two readings combine into a rule nothing else in the standard states: that the “before” campaign is made in a hemi free field and the “after” one against a reflecting surface.
- Evidence: the two equations and the symbol list on printed page 11, settled by the NOTE that closes the same clause, “It is preferable to choose receiver positions where corrections and are essentially the same”, which is advice only if each campaign’s correction follows its own receiver position rather than being fixed by the campaign. Verified on PDF page 15 (printed p. 11) of ISO 10847:1997.
- Consequence for the standard’s own tables: none.
- Library behaviour:
measured_insertion_loss_indirecttakesreceiver_type_beforeandreceiver_type_after, each of them ‘hemi_free_field’ or ‘reflecting_surface’ and each defaulting to the former, and reads its correction out ofRECEIVER_CORRECTIONS, which holds the printed 0 dB and 6 dB. The result carries both corrections so that a report shows which was applied to which campaign. - Status: not reported.
Created and maintained by José Manuel Requena PlensORCIDAbout the maintainerRelease notesChangelogAll projects