Errata in EN 15610
These are the 2 entries of the errata registry on EN 15610:2009, in the order the registry lists them. The registry’s introduction says how each claim is checked against the printed page and what the status of an entry means.
EN 15610:2009, Annex B, B.9.2 (a spike-removal loop that asks for no change of sign and never ends on a bend)
Section titled “EN 15610:2009, Annex B, B.9.2 (a spike-removal loop that asks for no change of sign and never ends on a bend)”- Location: Annex B (informative), B.9.2, the spike-removal section of the listing of RoughProcess.m, printed pp. 23 and 24; clause 7.2, printed pp. 12 and 13.
- The print: the listing repeats its sweep under
while min(d2rdx2) <-10^7, and inside it treats a sample as a spike onlyif (y < -10^7) && (d1 ~= d2), the second derivative and a change of sign of the first, and interpolates across it onlyif height > w^2/3. Clause 7.2 c) identifies a spike “by the criteria and a change of sign for ”, removes it when with m, and ends: “The spike removal procedure shall be repeated until no further spike is detected.” - The problem: the loop condition leaves out the change of sign that 7.2 c) and the sweep inside the loop both ask of a spike. Wherever the record bends sharply without a maximum or a minimum, its second derivative falls below with no spike there by 7.2 c), no sweep changes the record, and the loop does not terminate. A rail rising 20 µm per millimetre and then 5 µm per millimetre, sampled every millimetre, is such a bend: at the bend, and is positive on both sides of it. That is where the listing departs from the clause it illustrates. On a peak that 7.2 c) does detect and that the height test keeps as roughness a wheel feels, the listing is no worse than the clause read literally: a ridge 200 µm high, sampled every millimetre, whose edges the listing’s slope rule places 42 mm apart, has at its tip and m below m; it is detected on every pass and kept, so neither the listing nor “until no further spike is detected” ever stops on it.
- Evidence: the listing read on PDF pages 25 and 26 (printed pp. 23 and 24), and clause 7.2 on PDF pages 14 and 15 (printed pp. 12 and 13) of BS EN 15610:2009, the UK implementation of EN 15610:2009 (approved by CEN on 16 April 2009). The non-termination is a run of the listing’s loop, transcribed line for line, on the bend and on the ridge above.
- Library behaviour:
remove_roughness_spikesdetects a spike by both criteria of 7.2 c) and repeats its sweep until a sweep removes nothing, which is how it reads “until no further spike is detected” for a peak that is detected and kept. It returns the bend and the ridge above unchanged;test_a_bend_without_an_extremum_is_no_spikeandtest_a_broad_ridge_is_kept_and_the_sweep_endsintests/environment/sources/test_acoustic_roughness.pyhold it on both. - Status: unreported.
EN 15610:2009, Annex B, B.9.2 (Method B filters run forward and back, outside every class of EN 61260)
Section titled “EN 15610:2009, Annex B, B.9.2 (Method B filters run forward and back, outside every class of EN 61260)”- Location: Annex B (informative), B.9.2, the digital filtering section of the listing of RoughProcess.m, printed p. 25, described in B.6, printed p. 20; clause 7.4.3, printed p. 15, and clause 2, printed p. 5.
- The print: the listing sets the band edges
fsmin=fsc/(2^(1/6))andfsmax=fsc*(2^(1/6))about the centresfsc=1./wl_d, designs each band withorder=3;and[b,a]=butter(order,Wn);, filters withrf=filtfilt(b,a,rraw);and reportsspecdf(q)=std(rf);of the record left once 2 m are cut from either end. Clause 7.4.3 reads: “The digital filters shall comply with EN 61260”, and clause 2 dates that reference as EN 61260 (IEC 61260:1995). - The problem:
butter(3,Wn)designs a band-pass filter 3 dB down atfsminandfsmax, andfiltfiltruns it forward and then backward, so the filter the record actually goes through has the square of its magnitude response: 6.02 dB down at its own band edges. Taking the listing’sfscas the exact midband frequency and the base-two ratio its edges are built on, Table 1 of EN 61260:1995 allows a relative attenuation just inside a band edge of at most 4.5 dB, 5.0 dB and 5.5 dB for classes 0, 1 and 2, and 4.5.3 limits the filter integrated response , with of equation (14) and of equation (9), to dB, dB and dB. The squared response gives dB in every band ofwl_dfrom 0.5 m to 4 mm at 1 mm sampling, and dB in the 3.15 mm and 2.5 mm bands, where the sampling bends the response. The filters of the listing therefore meet no class of EN 61260 in any band, on either requirement, which is what 7.4.3 asks of them, and a band whose spectrum is flat across it reads about 0.6 dB low. The same filter run forward once would be 3.01 dB down at the edges, with from dB to dB, inside class 1. A comment of the same section, “used later for fsc(q)<50 ie lambda >0.02”, disagrees with the test the code makes,if fsc(q)>=20andelseif fsc(q)<20, which sends the bands longer than 0.05 m to the decimated record. - Evidence: the listing read on PDF page 27 (printed p. 25), B.6 on PDF
page 22 (printed p. 20), clause 7.4.3 on PDF page 17 (printed p. 15) and
clause 2 on PDF page 7 (printed p. 5) of BS EN 15610:2009, the UK
implementation of EN 15610:2009; Table 1 on PDF page 14 (printed p. 10),
equation (9) on PDF page 10 (printed p. 6), equations (13) and (14) on PDF
page 15 (printed p. 11) and 4.5.3 on PDF page 16 (printed p. 12) of
BS EN 61260:1996, which is IEC 61260:1995. The attenuations and
are a recomputation: the listing’s filters designed with
scipy.signal.butter, the same design as the MATLAB function, at 1 mm sampling (and on the record decimated by 10 forfsc<20), their response squared, read at the band edges and integrated by equation (14). - Library behaviour:
filtered_roughness_spectrumruns each band forward once through the order 4 Butterworth sections ofroughness_filter_bank, at the record’s own rate, a bank that is class 0 of EN 61260:1995 on Table 1 up to the Nyquist wavenumber of the record, on 4.5.3 and on 4.9;test_the_bank_is_class_0_on_table_1_of_en_61260_1995,test_the_bank_attenuates_class_0_beyond_g4_on_a_record,test_the_integrated_response_of_every_band_is_within_class_0andtest_the_summation_of_outputs_is_within_class_0intests/environment/sources/test_roughness_method_b.pyhold it there, and the conformance checks “EN 15610:2009 7.4.3 and EN 61260:1995 Table 1” and “EN 15610:2009 7.4.3 and EN 61260:1995 4.8 and Table 1” grade it band by band and on tones run through it. - Status: unreported.
Created and maintained by José Manuel Requena PlensORCIDAbout the maintainerRelease notesChangelogAll projects