Skip to content

Errata in RANDI 3.1 Physics Description

This is the entry of the errata registry on RANDI 3.1 Physics Description. The registry’s introduction says how each claim is checked against the printed page and what the status of an entry means.

RANDI 3.1 Physics Description (NRL, Breeding et al.), Table 2

Section titled “RANDI 3.1 Physics Description (NRL, Breeding et al.), Table 2”
  • Location: Table 2 (representative ship source levels).
  • The print: two cells deviate from the report’s own Eqs. (2) to (5) evaluated with the Table 1 average lengths and speeds: the Merchant value at 25 Hz (about 3 dB high) and the Tanker value at 300 Hz (about 1 dB low). The Fishing Vessel row is not reproducible from the Table 1 averages at all (a constant offset of about 3.8 dB suggests different assumed inputs).
  • The problem: the report does not state the exact inputs used for Table 2, and two cells contradict its own equations while every Large Tanker and Super Tanker cell agrees to 0.06 dB.
  • Evidence: recomputation of all 25 cells from Eqs. (2) to (5).
  • Library behaviour: the regression test pins the reproducible rows and excludes the contradicting cells with the rationale in the test.
  • Status: unreported (technical report rather than a standard).