Skip to content

Errata in Mechel (2008)

This is the entry of the errata registry on Mechel (2008). The registry’s introduction says how each claim is checked against the printed page and what the status of an entry means.

Mechel (2008), Table 3 (a wall impedance its own Equation (11) does not give)

Section titled “Mechel (2008), Table 3 (a wall impedance its own Equation (11) does not give)”
  • Location: Table 3, “Density and elastic constants of materials”, the row “PVC, 30% softener” on printed page 530 (PDF page 545), against Equation (11) on printed page 529 (PDF page 544). Non-normative source: a textbook.
  • The print: the row gives = 1250 kg/m3, = 48 Hz m and = 1220, with the modulus and the loss-factor columns empty. Equation (11), on the facing page, reads .
  • The problem: with this row’s own density and , that definition gives . The printed 1220 is 8.4 times it.
  • Evidence: the same expression reproduces the rest of the table over four decades of , from 20 to 1438: thirty-six of the other thirty-seven rows within 5 per cent and thirty-four within 3 per cent. The one other row outside that band is not a defect either, and shows what one looks like when it is not: “Plaster board” prints = 85 as a single value where its is the range 31 to 35, and 85 is the top of the band the equation gives rather than its middle. The conclusion does not turn on the value taken for , which the equation writes as a symbol: 400 gives 150 and 415 gives 144.6, against a printed 1220. Verified against the page as printed on PDF pages 544 and 545 (printed pp. 529 and 530) of Mechel (2008), Formulas of Acoustics, 2nd edition.
  • Consequence for the book’s own tables: that one cell. Nothing else in the document computes with it, and the row’s density and , which are the two columns this library reads, are consistent with each other.
  • Library behaviour: the catalogue holds the density, the and the loss factor of each row and does not hold , which is a wall impedance ratio rather than a property of the material. The row carries the discrepancy in its note. The tests test_the_printed_wall_impedance_follows_from_the_books_own_equation and test_the_one_row_that_does_not_is_the_one_the_errata_names in tests/solids/test_catalogue.py pin both halves of the evidence.
  • Status: not reported.
Edit page

Published , updated