Errata in Maa (1998)
This is the entry of the errata registry on Maa (1998). The registry’s introduction says how each claim is checked against the printed page and what the status of an entry means.
Maa (1998), “Potential of microperforated panel absorber”, JASA 104(5), Eq. (5b)
Section titled “Maa (1998), “Potential of microperforated panel absorber”, JASA 104(5), Eq. (5b)”- Location: Eq. (5b), the mass-reactance coefficient of the microperforated panel, printed as .
- The print: the first bracket term reads .
- The problem: the same paper’s Eq. (4), from which (5b) is factored, prints the term as , and only that form reproduces the Crandall low- limit of the paper’s own Eq. (3a): at the printed (5b) gives an internal mass factor of 2 instead of 4/3. The paper’s own Fig. 1 confirms it: with the plotted starts near () at , not at .
- Evidence: recomputation of both bracket variants against Eq. (4), Eq. (3a) and the Fig. 1 curve; the exact Bessel solution of Eq. (2) agrees with Eq. (4) within Maa’s stated only with the form (the 1 form errs by at low ). Verified on PDF page 2 (printed p. 2862) of Maa (1998), “Potential of microperforated panel absorber”, JASA 104(5), which carries Eq. (4) and Eq. (5b) fifteen lines apart on the same column.
- Library behaviour: implements the exact Eq. (2) (no approximation), so
the misprint does not enter the code; the regression test
test_maa_exact_vs_wide_range_approximationpins the exact solution to the corrected Eq. (4) form. - Status: unreported (journal paper; the correct form appears in Maa’s earlier 1975/1987 papers and in secondary literature).
Created and maintained by José Manuel Requena PlensORCIDAbout the maintainerRelease notesChangelogAll projects