Skip to content

Errata in ISO 3747

These are the 5 entries of the errata registry on ISO 3747:2010, in the order the registry lists them. The registry’s introduction says how each claim is checked against the printed page and what the status of an entry means.

ISO 3747:2010, E.4.2.6.2 (the sign of the direct-field level)

Section titled “ISO 3747:2010, E.4.2.6.2 (the sign of the direct-field level)”
  • Location: Annex E (informative), E.4.2.6.2 “Excess sound pressure, measurement distance effect, ”, the sentence giving the directly radiated pressure and the two sentences that build on it.
  • The print: “the directly radiated pressure is approximately dB. Rearranging Equation (A.1) using , gives dB”, and the sensitivity coefficient that follows, .
  • The problem: the direct field of a source over a reflecting plane falls with distance, dB; the printed plus sign makes it grow. The two sentences that follow hold only with the minus sign. Substituting dB into Eq. (A.1) rearranged, dB, gives the printed dB, whereas the plus sign gives ; and the of the sensitivity coefficient is , the derivative of , so the printed is the derivative of the minus-sign form. A sign misprint in an informative annex.
  • Evidence: the three consecutive sentences of E.4.2.6.2 read against each other and against Eq. (A.1). Verified on PDF page 47 (printed p. 38) and PDF page 30 (printed p. 21) of BS EN ISO 3747:2010.
  • Library behaviour: the Annex E uncertainty budget is not modelled; the library evaluates Eq. (A.1) as printed (excess_sound_pressure_level), which the misprint does not touch. No number changes.
  • Status: unreported.

ISO 3747:2010, E.4.2.5 (the altitude correction quoted against Annex C)

Section titled “ISO 3747:2010, E.4.2.5 (the altitude correction quoted against Annex C)”
  • Location: Annex E (informative), E.4.2.5 “Radiation impedance correction, ”, the sentences that size .
  • The print: “For altitudes less than 500 m above sea level, no meteorological correction is required. At 120 m altitude and 23 °C, the correction is 0 dB and at 500 m altitude, the correction is 0,6 dB. Assuming a triangular distribution for this uncertainty, the standard deviation is dB.”
  • The problem: the normative Annex C defines the correction as with the static pressure of Eq. (C.2), . At 23 °C that gives 0.07 dB at 120 m ( = 99.89 kPa, of which the pressure term is 0.06 dB) and 0.26 dB at 500 m ( = 95.46 kPa), not the printed 0.6 dB, and the arithmetic printed after it does not close either: , printed 0.3. No altitude below which “no meteorological correction is required” appears in Annex C. The informative example is inconsistent with the normative annex it cites.
  • Evidence: recomputation of Eq. (C.2) and from the printed constants (, = 5.255 3, = Pa, = 296 K). Verified on PDF page 46 (printed p. 37) and PDF page 36 (printed p. 27) of BS EN ISO 3747:2010.
  • Library behaviour: implements Annex C as printed: static_pressure_from_altitude evaluates Eq. (C.2) and the result’s c2 the correction, so a site at 500 m gets the 0.26 dB the annex gives. The Annex E budget is not modelled. Pinned by test_static_pressure_from_altitude_eq_c2 in tests/emission/test_sound_power_in_situ.py and by the conformance check “ISO 3747:2010 Eq. C.2”.
  • Status: unreported.

ISO 3747:2010, Table E.2 (the excess that lost its delta)

Section titled “ISO 3747:2010, Table E.2 (the excess that lost its delta)”
  • Location: Annex E (informative), Table E.2 “Uncertainty budget for determinations of …”, the sensitivity-coefficient cell of the (measurement distance) row.
  • The print: .
  • The problem: the quantity in the exponent is the excess of sound pressure level over the free field, of Eq. (A.1), not a level ; no quantity called is defined anywhere in the standard. E.4.2.6.2, which derives this very coefficient, prints it as , and its worked extreme ( = 7.1 dB, = 6 m) reproduces the 0.6 quoted there only with the excess in the exponent (). The delta was dropped in the table.
  • Evidence: the table cell read against the text that derives it, verified on PDF page 44 (printed p. 35) and PDF page 47 (printed p. 38) of BS EN ISO 3747:2010. Table E.2 is specific to this part: the corresponding row of ISO 3744:2010 carries the free-field coefficient with no excess factor at all, so the slip is not inherited from the family.
  • Library behaviour: the Annex E uncertainty budget is not modelled, and the excess itself is evaluated from Eq. (A.1) by excess_sound_pressure_level. No number changes.
  • Status: unreported.

ISO 3747:2010, Table E.2 (the sampling coefficient its own clause contradicts)

Section titled “ISO 3747:2010, Table E.2 (the sampling coefficient its own clause contradicts)”
  • Location: Annex E (informative), Table E.2 “Uncertainty budget for determinations of …”, the sensitivity-coefficient cell of the (sampling) row.
  • The print: .
  • The problem: E.4.2.6.3, the clause that derives that very row, prints the opposite together with its reason: “Sampling directly affects the total uncertainty so ”. The budget of E.4.2.12 sides with the clause and not with the table: its sixth term is , which is the 0.7 dB contribution E.4.2.6.3 quotes taken at . The neighbouring row settles that 0.5 is no blanket convention for instrument rows, because E.4.2.7 sets and earns it: repeated readings on one meter let the systematic errors cancel, which halves the coefficient, and the clause then reproduces the budget’s own term ( dB, quoted there as 0.3 dB for each of the two sources, and dB, the 0.4 that E.4.2.12 sums). The sampling row carries no such derivation, and cannot carry one: is defined on the difference , which already spans both sources, so there is no second contribution to halve. The family agrees with the clause: the corresponding row of Table H.2 in ISO 3744:2010 carries , and its H.4.2.9 prints as well.
  • Evidence: the table cell, the clause that derives it and the budget that sums it, read on PDF pages 44, 47 and 50 (printed pp. 35, 38 and 41) of BS EN ISO 3747:2010; the family comparison on PDF pages 79 and 82 (printed pp. 70 and 73) of BS EN ISO 3744:2010.
  • Library behaviour: the Annex E uncertainty budget is not modelled. The reproducibility the library reports is the tabulated of Table 2, read by accuracy grade. No number changes.
  • Status: unreported.

ISO 3747:2010, E.4.2.3 (the equation the derivative is taken of)

Section titled “ISO 3747:2010, E.4.2.3 (the equation the derivative is taken of)”
  • Location: Annex E (informative), E.4.2.3 “Sound pressure measurement repeatability, ”, the sentence introducing the sensitivity coefficient .
  • The print: “It is obtained from the derivative of [Equation (E.1)], with respect to .”
  • The problem: Equation (E.1) is the standard deviation of the operating and mounting conditions, , which contains no and cannot be differentiated with respect to . The model that carries is Equation (E.2), printed on the facing page, and differentiating it (with substituted from Eq. 7) does give the printed . A cross-reference misprint: (E.1) for (E.2).
  • Evidence: verified on PDF page 45 (printed p. 36), which carries the sentence and the coefficient, against PDF page 41 (printed p. 32) for Eq. (E.1) and PDF page 42 (printed p. 33) for Eq. (E.2), of BS EN ISO 3747:2010. ISO 3741:2010 prints the same coefficient as “the derivative of with respect to ” with no equation number, so the wrong number is this part’s own.
  • Library behaviour: the Annex E uncertainty budget is not modelled, so no library number depends on it. Recorded so that a future reader chasing the derivation is not sent to the wrong equation.
  • Status: unreported.
Edit page

Published , updated