Skip to content

Errata in ISO 3744

These are the 3 entries of the errata registry on ISO 3744:2010, in the order the registry lists them. The registry’s introduction says how each claim is checked against the printed page and what the status of an entry means.

ISO 3744:2010, 8.3.4, Equation (21) (a time-integrated level compared with a time-averaged one)

Section titled “ISO 3744:2010, 8.3.4, Equation (21) (a time-integrated level compared with a time-averaged one)”
  • Location: clause 8.3.4, Equation (21) and the symbol list beneath it (PDF page 31, printed p. 25) of ISO 3744:2010, read against the definitions of clauses 3.3 and 3.4 (PDF page 9, printed p. 3). The same construction is printed as ISO 3741:2010 Equation (25) (PDF page 33, printed p. 24, with its symbol list on PDF page 34, printed p. 25) as ISO 3747:2010 Equation (14) (PDF pages 22 and 23, printed pp. 13 and 14), as ISO 3743-1:2010 Equation (19) in clause 8.2.3 (PDF page 25, printed p. 16), and as ISO 3746:2010 Equation (15) in clause 8.4.2 (PDF page 25, printed p. 16), which is the survey-grade route the library takes for grade='survey'.
  • The print: dB with , where “is the mean frequency-band or A-weighted single event time-integrated sound pressure level” and “is the mean frequency-band or A-weighted time-averaged sound pressure level of the background noise”, followed by “The integration time and other measurement parameters shall be the same for the measurement of the single event time-integrated sound pressure level and of the background noise level .”
  • The problem: the two levels do not share a reference quantity, and the correction subtracts one energy from another. By clause 3.4, is re ; by clause 3.3, is re . Their difference is a ratio of energies only when s. Over the common interval the background contributes the energy (the identity of clause 3.4 NOTE 1), so the printed exceeds the signal-to-background energy ratio by and is under-estimated for every s: a burst whose energy is 6 dB above the background’s in a 10 s interval reads as 16 dB above it and earns no correction, where the criterion of 8.2.3 puts at its largest admissible value, 1.3 dB. The twin chain of 8.2, where both levels are time-averaged, has no such term, and 8.3.3 requires the single event levels to be averaged “in the same way as for the time-averaged sound pressure levels described in 8.2.2”, so the intended reading is the one under which the two chains coincide for a source that is steady over , , and that is the reading under which the insistence on one integration time for both measurements does any work.
  • Evidence: Verified on PDF page 31 (printed p. 25) of ISO 3744:2010 for the equation and its symbol list, and on PDF page 9 (printed p. 3) for the definitions of clauses 3.3 and 3.4 with NOTE 1; the same construction read on PDF pages 33 and 34 (printed pp. 24 and 25) of BS EN ISO 3741:2010, on PDF pages 22 and 23 (printed pp. 13 and 14) of BS EN ISO 3747:2010 and on PDF page 25 (printed p. 16) of BS EN ISO 3743-1:2010.
  • Library behaviour: sound_energy_pressure, sound_energy_reverberation and sound_energy_comparison compare the background as its exposure over the same interval, , and require integration_time with the background of the source under test, which is the one compared against an event level. The reference source of sound_energy_comparison is steady, so reference_background_levels is corrected by the time-averaged rule of 9.1.2 instead and takes no window; the criteria and the clamp of 8.2.3 (and of 9.1.2 in ISO 3741) are then applied to that margin. tests/emission/test_sound_energy.py pins dB for a 78 dB burst over a 62 dB background in a 10 s window, and field by field on both families; the conformance report carries the identity as “ISO 3744:2010 Eq. 23 / clause 3.4 NOTE 1”. sound_energy_hard_walled reads ISO 3743-1:2010 Equation (19) the same way and requires integration_time with the background; test_steady_source_energy_is_power_plus_10_lg_t in tests/emission/test_sound_power_hard_walled.py and the conformance check “ISO 3743-1:2010 Eq. 20 / clause 3.4 NOTE 1” pin the identity there.
  • Status: unreported.

ISO 3744:2010, 8.3.4 (the correction named K_1i in the text and K_1 in Equation (21))

Section titled “ISO 3744:2010, 8.3.4 (the correction named K_1i in the text and K_1 in Equation (21))”
  • Location: clause 8.3.4, first sentence and Equation (21) (PDF page 31, printed p. 25).
  • The print: “The background noise correction, , shall be calculated using Equation (21):” followed by dB with formed from the two means over the measurement surface, and .
  • The problem: the sentence names a per-position correction and the equation defines a single one from surface means. The twin clause 8.2.3 names in both places and forms it from the same surface means (Equation (16)), and 8.3.5 subtracts the unsubscripted in Equation (22). The subscript is the per-microphone convention of ISO 3741:2010 clauses 9.1.2 and 9.2.2 (, Equations (14) and (25)), where each position is corrected before the average, and does not belong to this clause.
  • Evidence: Verified on PDF page 31 (printed p. 25) of ISO 3744:2010, against clause 8.2.3 on PDF page 29 (printed p. 23).
  • Library behaviour: sound_energy_pressure forms one per band from the surface means, as Equation (21) prints it and as sound_power_pressure does for Equation (16); no per-position correction is applied in the ISO 3744 chain. No change was required.
  • Status: unreported.

ISO 3744:2010, H.4.2.7 (the altitude correction and the divisor under it)

Section titled “ISO 3744:2010, H.4.2.7 (the altitude correction and the divisor under it)”
  • Location: Annex H (informative), H.4.2.7 “Meteorological and radiation impedance corrections”, the paragraph that sizes from the Annex G correction.
  • The print: “At 120 m altitude and 23 °C the correction is zero and at 500 m altitude the correction is 0,6 dB. Assuming a triangular distribution for this uncertainty, the standard deviation is .”
  • The problem: two independent defects in one sentence pair. (a) Annex G, which is normative and which this paragraph points at, gives dB at 500 m and 23.0 °C, not 0.6 dB. The reading is self-validating: the same two equations give dB at 120 m and 23.0 °C, which is the “zero” the same sentence prints, so the constants and the temperature terms are being read as the standard intends. 0.6 dB is reached at about 697 m at 23.0 °C, or at 500 m only if the air is at 30.1 °C. (b) , not 0.3. The quotient does not give the result printed beside it: 0.3 dB is exactly , so either the divisor or the result is wrong. For a triangular distribution of half-width the standard deviation is , which is the divisor the sentence names.
  • Evidence: H.4.2.7 read on PDF page 82 (printed p. 73), against Annex G Equations (G.1) and (G.2) with m, , K and K on PDF pages 73 and 74 (printed pp. 64 and 65), all of BS EN ISO 3744:2010. Both values were recomputed from the printed equations alone.
  • Library behaviour: the Annex H uncertainty budget is not modelled, so no published number depends on either figure. The Annex G correction itself is evaluated from Equations (G.1) and (G.2) by reference_atmosphere_correction, and the conformance check “ISO 3744:2010 Annex G / H.4.2.7” pins the half of the paragraph that is right: the correction vanishes at 120 m and 23 °C.
  • Status: unreported.
Edit page

Published , updated