Skip to content

Errata in ISO/PAS 20065

This is the entry of the errata registry on ISO/PAS 20065:2016. The registry’s introduction says how each claim is checked against the printed page and what the status of an entry means.

ISO/PAS 20065:2016, clause 5.3.4 (edge steepness of a distinct tone)

Section titled “ISO/PAS 20065:2016, clause 5.3.4 (edge steepness of a distinct tone)”
  • Location: clause 5.3.4, Formulae (10)/(11) (printed p. 9), the minimum edge steepness of a distinct tone.
  • The print: the two edges are scaled differently: and .
  • The problem: the parent standard DIN 45681:2005-03 prints on both edges (Gleichungen (10)/(11), printed p. 14), and its executable Anhang J reference program does the same (Frequenz(i)/Sqr(2)). The two prints cannot both be satisfied. Neither ISO factor is the DIN one: on the lower edge , so the ISO print returns a level difference smaller and is therefore stricter; on the upper edge the divisor is absent altogether, so the ISO print returns larger and is more lenient. An earlier revision of this entry had the two directions the other way round and described the upper edge as “halved”, where in fact the divisor is missing rather than halved. Borderline tones with one-sided edge steepness between and flip classification between the two readings.
  • Evidence: side-by-side comparison of the ISO print, the DIN 45681 print and the DIN Anhang J program. The DIN radicals are exactly the case the page rule exists for: pdftotext drops the √ glyph from both DIN formulae, so the extracted text reads f_T/2 and matches the ISO print, while the page itself reads f_T/√2. Verified on PDF page 13 (printed p. 9) of ISO/PAS 20065:2016 and PDF page 14 (printed p. 14) of DIN 45681:2005-03.
  • Library behaviour: follows the DIN/ reading (it matches the only executable reference), with the choice recorded in _tone_audibility.py.
  • Status: unreported.