Skip to content

Errata in ISO/PAS 1996

This is the entry of the errata registry on ISO/PAS 1996-3:2022. The registry’s introduction says how each claim is checked against the printed page and what the status of an entry means.

ISO/PAS 1996-3:2022, Clause 5 (cross-references of r and d)

Section titled “ISO/PAS 1996-3:2022, Clause 5 (cross-references of r and d)”
  • Location: Clause 5, Formula (2), the definitions of the symbols of the prominence .
  • The print: “r is the onset rate (OR) as defined in 3.4” and “d is the level difference (LD) as defined in 3.5”.
  • The problem: the two cross-references are swapped. The document’s own terms and definitions set 3.4 as the level difference LD (“difference in decibels of L_pAF between the level of the end point L_e and the level of the starting point L_s of the onset”) and 3.5 as the onset rate OR (“slope in decibels per second of the straight line that gives the best approximation to the onset”). Read literally, Formula (2) would take three times the logarithm of a level difference plus twice the logarithm of a slope, inverting the weights the method assigns to the two quantities. The spelled-out names in the same list (“the onset rate (OR)”, “the level difference (LD)”) and the units given for each (“dB/s” for , “dB” for ) make the intended reading unambiguous.
  • Evidence: side-by-side reading of 3.4, 3.5 and the Clause 5 symbol list; the units printed with each symbol contradict the clause numbers printed with them.
  • Library behaviour: implements the spelled-out reading, weighting the onset rate by 3 and the level difference by 2 (predicted_prominence in impulsive_sound.py), which is also the NT ACOU 112:2002 form the PAS carries over.
  • Status: unreported.