Errata in ISO 10848
This is the entry of the errata registry on ISO 10848-1:2006. The registry’s introduction says how each claim is checked against the printed page and what the status of an entry means.
ISO 10848-1:2006, Clause 8.1.1, Formula (20) (spurious π in the critical frequency)
Section titled “ISO 10848-1:2006, Clause 8.1.1, Formula (20) (spurious π in the critical frequency)”- Location: Clause 8.1.1, Formula (20), the thin-plate critical frequency used by the test-facility flanking criterion of Formula (19).
- The print: .
- The problem: the constant 1.8 is itself the rounded of the thin-plate dispersion relation, so the extra double-counts it and would misplace by a factor (e.g. a 100 mm concrete element with : 187 Hz without the , 59 Hz with it, far from any measured coincidence dip).
- Evidence: derivation from the thin-plate dispersion relation (Hopkins, Sound Insulation (2007), Eq. 2.201, ); ISO 12354-1:2017 prints the same -free form in its symbol definitions ().
- Library behaviour: implements the -free form
(
phonometry.building.measurement.flanking_transmission.critical_frequency), with a misprint note in the docstring. - Status: corrected upstream: ISO 10848-1:2017 (second edition) prints the -free form in its Formula (5), , confirming the 2006 print as a misprint. No report is needed. The entry is retained because the library cites the 2006 edition, whose print carries the defect; the 2017 edition stands as the confirmation.
Created and maintained by José Manuel Requena PlensORCIDAbout the maintainerRelease notesChangelogAll projects