Errata in Harris (1995)
These are the 2 entries of the errata registry on Harris (1995), in the order the registry lists them. The registry’s introduction says how each claim is checked against the printed page and what the status of an entry means.
Harris 3e (1995), Tables 32.1 to 32.8 (nineteen double-unit pairs whose two halves are not each other)
Section titled “Harris 3e (1995), Tables 32.1 to 32.8 (nineteen double-unit pairs whose two halves are not each other)”- Location: Tables 32.1 to 32.8, the impact insulation of floor-ceiling constructions, on printed folios 32.8 to 32.15 (PDF pages 750 to 757), in chapter 32, “Aislamiento del sonido transmitido por estructuras”, of the Spanish edition. Non-normative source: a handbook.
- The print: every dimension and every mass of these eight tables is printed twice, SI first and the US customary value in parentheses after it, inside the running description of each construction: “Losa de 10 cm (4 in)”, “cada 40,6 cm (16 in)”, “alfombra de 1,5 kg/m2 (44 oz/yd2)”. Three hundred and twenty-one such pairs are printed over the eight tables.
- The problem: nineteen of the three hundred and twenty-one pairs are not each
other. The inch is 2.54 cm exactly, the pound is 0.45359237 kg exactly and
the yard 0.9144 m exactly, so one pound per cubic foot is 16.0185 kg/m3, one
pound per square yard 0.54249 kg/m2 and one ounce per square yard 33.906
g/m2, and each pair is decided by arithmetic alone. On these pages the US
customary half is the measurement and the SI half its translation, so a pair
whose imperial half is a whole number or a fraction is read in that
direction only, and one whose imperial half is itself printed as a rounded
decimal is allowed either. A pair counts as sound when the SI half is the
conversion rounded or truncated to the precision it is printed to, which
forgives the whole of this chapter’s loose rounding: “60 cm (24 in)” and
“2,5 cm (1 in)” are truncations of 60.96 and 2.54 and no more than that, and
row 17 prints “36,9 cm (14,5 in)”, where 36.9 cm is 14.53 in and the page
would print that as the 14.5 in beside it. The nineteen below survive that
test. Each one names the row the page numbers, the pair as it is set, and
the conversion that fails:
- Row 9 (PDF page 750, printed folio 32.8): “30,8 cm (16 in)” for the batten spacing. cm, which these eight tables print as 40.6 cm eighteen times over.
- Row 11 (PDF page 751, printed folio 32.9): “53,2 cm (21 in)” for the rib spacing. cm, which row 38 prints as 53.3 cm.
- Row 14 (PDF page 752, printed folio 32.10): “15,6 cm (6 in)” for the slab. cm, which these eight tables print as 15.2 cm eleven times over.
- Row 18 (PDF page 752, printed folio 32.10): “36,7 cm (14,5 in)” for the beam spacing. cm, which rows 13 and 15 print as 36.8 cm.
- Row 22 (PDF page 753, printed folio 32.11): “60,1 cm (24 in)” for the joist spacing. cm, which rows 26, 27, 33 and 38 print as 61 cm.
- Row 23 (PDF page 753, printed folio 32.11): “60,1 cm (24 in)” for the joist spacing, the same pair again.
- Row 26 (PDF page 754, printed folio 32.12): “32,3 cm (11,75 in)” for the total thickness. cm, and 32.3 cm is 12.72 in, so neither half is the other.
- Row 27 (PDF page 754, printed folio 32.12): “1,89 cm (0,78 in)” for the oak strip floor. cm, which row 26 prints as 1.98 cm for the same floor.
- Row 28 (PDF page 754, printed folio 32.12): “1,89 cm (0,78 in)” for the same oak strip floor.
- Row 28 (PDF page 754, printed folio 32.12): “31,6 cm (12,5 in)” for the total thickness. cm, which rows 16 and 18 print as 31.8 cm and row 25 as 31.7 cm.
- Row 29 (PDF page 754, printed folio 32.12): “60,8 cm (24 in)” for the resilient channels. cm.
- Row 31 (PDF page 755, printed folio 32.13): “10,1 cm (2 in)” for the batten section. cm, which these eight tables print as 5.1 cm twenty-two times over, the same row included.
- Row 34A (PDF page 755, printed folio 32.13): “7,5 cm (3 in)” for the furring strips. cm, which these eight tables print as 7.6 cm ten times over.
- Row 35A (PDF page 756, printed folio 32.14): “410 kg/m3 (26,1 lb/ft3)” for the compressed paper-pulp floor board. kg/m3, and 410 kg/m3 is 25.6 lb/ft3, so neither half is the other. The page does not say which of the two carries the defect, and no other cell of the eight tables settles it: row 5 prints 35.2 kg/m3 (2.2 lb/ft3) and row 37A 2370 kg/m3 (148 lb/ft3), and both of those convert correctly, which makes this a property of this cell and not of the chapter.
- Row 35B (PDF page 756, printed folio 32.14): “60,1 cm (24 in)” for the steel joist spacing.
- Row 36B (PDF page 756, printed folio 32.14): “60,1 cm (24 in)” for the steel joist spacing.
- Row 37A (PDF page 756, printed folio 32.14): “1,5 kg/m2 (3,4 lb/yd2)” for the diamond mesh and metal lath. kg/m2, and row 38 converts 4.14 lb/yd2 to 2.25 kg/m2 with that same factor.
- Row 38 (PDF page 756, printed folio 32.14): “1,81 kg/m2 (40 oz/yd2)” for the hair underlay. g/m2, which row 28 prints as 1.4 kg/m2 for the same cloth.
- Row 38 (PDF page 756, printed folio 32.14): “1,99 kg/m2 (44 oz/yd2)” for the wool pile carpet. g/m2, which rows 28 and 30 print as 1.5 kg/m2 for the same cloth. The two carpet cells of this row are both 1.334 of their own conversion, so one wrong factor was applied to the pair rather than two digits slipping.
- Evidence: Verified on PDF pages 750 to 757 (printed pp. 32.8-32.15) of Harris (ed.), Manual de medidas acústicas y control del ruido 3e (1995), the Spanish edition of Handbook of Acoustical Measurements and Noise Control. Two readers transcribed the eight tables independently and agreed on every one of these nineteen pairs; each was then read again on its own page, enlarged, before being listed here. The three hundred and twenty-one pairs were converted and compared one by one rather than by sampling, which is what makes the list closed rather than a sample of what a reader happened to notice. The near misses it leaves off are the ones the rule above forgives, and three of them are named there.
- What the library does: publishes every one of these descriptions exactly
as the page sets them. The seventeen rows that carry one of the nineteen
pairs are marked in
PUBLISHED_IMPACT_INSULATION: the cell is recorded inmisprinted, quoting the printed pair and the conversion that fails, so a reader reproducing the book sees what the book says and a reader using the catalogue is told not to. Eighteen of the nineteen sit inside the running description, where this catalogue serves no quantity from them and nothing else follows. The nineteenth is row 35A’s density, which is the one cell of the nineteen this catalogue would lift into a field of its own, solayer_density_kg_m3is left empty there andwhy_missinghands back both printed halves rather than choosing one. Rows 5 and 37A, whose densities convert, are served normally. - Status: unreported.
Harris 3e (1995), Table 30.2 (five pile weights whose two halves are not each other)
Section titled “Harris 3e (1995), Table 30.2 (five pile weights whose two halves are not each other)”- Location: Table 30.2, “Absorción del sonido de alfombras sobre hormigón desnudo”, column “Peso del pelo kg/m (oz/yd)”, on printed folio 30.22 (PDF page 704), in chapter 30 of the Spanish edition. Non-normative source: a handbook.
- The print: every pile weight is printed twice, SI first and the US customary value in parentheses: “1,2 (35)”, “1,5 (43)” and so on, eleven pairs in the table.
- The problem: one ounce per square yard is kg/m by
definition, and five of the eleven pairs are not each other under the
criterion the Chapter 32 entry uses (the SI half is the conversion rounded or
truncated to the precision it is printed to):
- “2,3 (66)”, “3,1 (88)” and “2,1 (60)”: , and . All three are what kg/m per oz/yd gives, a factor that also reproduces every pair of Tables 30.2 and 30.3 that does hold, which is how these three come out a tenth high: the metric column follows a factor 3 per cent above the definition.
- “1,3 (32)”: , and gives ; neither reaches .
- “1,1 (3,2)”: oz/yd is kg/m. The same carpet, knotted, cut nylon with a pile of 14 mm, is printed “1,1 (32)” in Table 30.3, so the imperial half has a stray decimal comma.
- Evidence: Verified on PDF page 704 (printed p. 30.22) of Harris (ed.), Manual de medidas acústicas y control del ruido 3.ª ed. (1995); both independent readings of the page and a crop of the column print all five pairs as quoted. All eight pairs of Table 30.3, on the same page and the next, hold.
- What the library does: in
PUBLISHED_CARPETSthe four rows whose kilograms are in doubt serve no pile weight and mark the cellmisprinted, quoting the pair; the fifth serves its 1.1 kg/m and says in its note that the ounces lost a digit. - Status: unreported.
Created and maintained by José Manuel Requena PlensORCIDAbout the maintainerRelease notesChangelogAll projects