# Errata in ISO 717

> One page of the phonometry documentation, as Markdown. Index: https://docs.jmrp.io/phonometry/llms.txt

Canonical: https://docs.jmrp.io/phonometry/reference/errata/iso-717/
Language: en
Alternate: https://docs.jmrp.io/phonometry/es/reference/errata/iso-717/index.md
Version: phonometry 4.0.0
Install: pip install "phonometry[full]"
Author: José Manuel Requena Plens (https://orcid.org/0000-0003-1250-6212)
Published: 2026-10-28
Updated: 2026-11-16T21:36:14Z
License: MIT (https://github.com/jmrplens/phonometry/blob/main/LICENSE)
Summary: Errata in ISO 717: 3 defects in the printed text, with the evidence and what phonometry does about each.

---

These are the 3 entries of the [errata registry](https://docs.jmrp.io/phonometry/reference/errata/) on ISO 717-2:2020 and ISO 717-1:2020, in the order the registry lists them. The registry's introduction says how each claim is checked against the printed page and what the status of an entry means.

## ISO 717-2:2020, Annex C, example C.1 (CI of the bare floor)

- **Location:** Annex C, Table C.1 (printed p. 17) and the accompanying $C_I$
  computation printed in the same cell.
- **The print:** $L_{n,\text{sum}} = 83{,}523\,8\ldots = 84\ \text{dB}$ and
  $C_I = 84 - 15 - 79 = -10\ \text{dB}$ for the bare-floor example.
- **The problem:** two independent defects in the same cell. (a) Clause A.2.1
  defines $C_I$ from the energy sum over 100 Hz to 2500 Hz (the first fifteen
  one-third-octave bands); the printed value only reproduces if the 3150 Hz
  band is included, contradicting A.2.1. The correct sum over 100 Hz to 2500
  Hz is 83.2613 dB, rounded 83, giving $C_I = -11$. (b) Even read as the
  sixteen-band sum the printed digits are wrong in the last place: the
  bare-floor $L_n$ column sums to 83.523 4 dB, not the printed 83.523 **8**
  dB. The defect is confined to that cell, since the with-covering column of
  the same table prints $L_{n,\text{sum}} = 76.059\,3\ldots$ and recomputes
  to 76.059 29 dB, reproducing every printed digit. Neither (a) nor (b)
  changes the rounded 84 dB, so only (a) moves $C_I$.
- **Evidence:** independent recomputation of both sums from the printed
  per-band levels (16 bands 83.523 38 dB, 15 bands 83.261 27 dB, with-covering
  16 bands 76.059 29 dB); the 2013 edition of the same example prints
  $C_I = -11$. Verified on PDF page 23 (printed p. 17) and PDF page 17
  (printed p. 11) of ISO 717-2:2020, and of PDF page 22 (printed p. 14) of ISO
  717-2:2013.
- **Library behaviour:** implements A.2.1 as written and pins $C_I = -11$ with
  the 2013 print as the oracle
  ([`tests/reference_data/`](https://github.com/jmrplens/phonometry/blob/main/tests/reference_data), conformance check
  "ISO 717-2 Annex C, Table C.1").
- **Status:** unreported.

## ISO 717-2:2020, Annex C, example C.2 (covered floor: 800 Hz value and CI chain)

- **Location:** Annex C, Table C.2 (printed p. 18), the $\Delta L_w$ /
  $\Delta L_\text{lin}$ worked example.
- **The print:** (a) the 800 Hz reference-floor value is printed as 71,0 dB;
  (b) the $C_I$ line prints
  $L_{n,\text{sum}} = 75{,}252\,7\ldots = 75\ \text{dB}$ and
  $C_I = 75 - 15 - 63 = -3\ \text{dB}$, feeding
  $\Delta L_\text{lin} = 78 - 11 - (63 - 3) = 7\ \text{dB}$.
- **The problem:** two independent defects. (a) The normative Table 4
  reference floor is 71.5 dB at 800 Hz, and the column itself is a clean +0.5
  dB per one-third octave ramp from 67.0 dB at 100 Hz to 72.0 dB at 1000 Hz,
  which the printed 71.0 dB breaks by repeating the 630 Hz cell. The misprint
  propagates along its own row and into the table's total, three further cells
  the table prints and this entry previously did not name: the
  $L_{n,r,0} - \Delta L$ cell at 800 Hz is printed 64.0 dB
  ($= 71.0 - 7.0$) where 71.5 gives 64.5; the unfavourable deviation is
  printed 3.0 dB ($= 64.0 - 61$) where the corrected cell gives 3.5; and the
  printed “Sum 27,9” is the sum of the thirteen unfavourable deviations
  including that 3.0, where the corrected chain gives 28.4. None of it moves
  the rating: 28.4 dB is still below the 32.0 dB shift criterion, so
  $L_{n,w,r} = 63\ \text{dB}$ and $\Delta L_w = 15\ \text{dB}$ either way. (b)
  The printed 75.2527 dB is exactly the energy sum of the *wrong column over
  the wrong range*: the measured floor "with covering" over all sixteen bands
  100 Hz to 3150 Hz. A.2.1 defines $C_I$ from the reference floor with
  covering (the $L_{n,r,0} - \Delta L$ column) over 100 Hz to 2500 Hz (15
  bands), which gives 75.674 dB (printed chain) or 75.710 dB (corrected 800 Hz
  cell), both round to 76 dB, so $C_{I,r} = 76 - 15 - 63 = -2$ either way,
  giving $C_{I,\Delta} = -11 - (-2) = -9$ and
  $\Delta L_\text{lin} = 6\ \text{dB}$, not the printed −3 / −8 / 7 dB chain.
- **Evidence:** independent recomputation of every candidate sum and of every
  cell of the 800 Hz row from the printed per-band values; the printed 75.2527
  reproduces to all printed digits only as the 16-band sum of the
  with-covering column, and every other cell of the $L_{n,r,0} - \Delta L$ and
  deviation columns reproduces exactly from the printed reference floor, so
  the 800 Hz row is the only one that does not. Verified on PDF page 24
  (printed p. 18) and PDF page 13 (printed p. 7) of ISO 717-2:2020.
- **Library behaviour:** derives the covered reference floor from the
  normative Table 4 values and sums per A.2.1, pinning
  $\Delta L_w = 15\ \text{dB}$ and $C_{I,\Delta} = -9$; the conformance check
  notes the provenance explicitly.
- **Status:** unreported.

## ISO 717-1:2020, Annex E, Figures E.3 and E.2 (reference curves drawn off Table E.1)

- **Location:** Annex E, Figure E.3 "Reference curve for standard wall with
  medium critical frequency" (printed p. 24), against the lightweight-wall
  column of Table E.1 (printed pp. 24 and 25). The same drawing is Figure B.3
  of ISO 10140-5:2010+A1:2014 (printed p. 15), against the same column of its
  Table B.1 (printed p. 16).
- **The print:** the NOTE to E.1 says that Figures E.1, E.2 and E.3 "as well as
  Table E.1 give typical smoothed values" of the reference curves. Table E.1
  prints the lightweight wall as 21,3, 23,3 and 25,3 dB at 50, 63 and 80 Hz, a
  plateau of 27,0 dB from 100 Hz to 500 Hz, then 28,0 dB at 630 Hz rising to
  44,6 dB at 3 150 Hz and 49,4 dB at 5 000 Hz.
- **The problem:** Figure E.3 does not draw that curve. Read against its own
  gridlines at the band centres, its plateau lies at 25.9 dB, 1.1 dB under the
  table, and its rising branch runs one third-octave to the left of the
  table's: the figure reads 30.5 dB at 630 Hz, 35.3 dB at 1 000 Hz and
  42.5 dB at 2 000 Hz, where the table prints 30.5, 35.1 and 42.3 dB one band
  higher, at 800, 1 250 and 2 500 Hz, and 28.0, 32.8 and 40.0 dB at 630,
  1 000 and 2 000 Hz. The line stops near 2.2 kHz, so the figure has no
  curve for the table's 2 500 Hz to 5 000 Hz. Only the 50 Hz to 80 Hz start
  of the line agrees with the table. The drawing has been carried unchanged
  from ISO 10140-5, whose 2021 edition dropped both the figure and the table in
  favour of ISO 717-1. Figure E.2, redrawn for the 2020 edition, departs from
  its column as well, by less: its knee sits near 230 Hz instead of 250 Hz, so
  its rising branch runs up to 1.2 dB above the table from 315 Hz to 630 Hz
  (45.6 dB at 400 Hz where the table prints 44.4 dB), while Figure B.2 of
  ISO 10140-5:2010+A1:2014 follows the same column within 0.3 dB. Figure E.1
  follows its column within 0.3 dB.
- **Evidence:** the line of each figure read at every band centre of the table
  it illustrates; Figure E.3 gives 25.9 dB at 125, 160, 250 and 315 Hz, 28.0 dB
  at 500 Hz, 30.5 dB at 630 Hz, 35.3 dB at 1 000 Hz, 37.7 dB at 1 250 Hz and
  42.5 dB at 2 000 Hz, and no line at 2 500 Hz and above; Figure E.2 gives
  40.7, 42.8, 45.6, 48.0 and 50.4 dB at 250, 315, 400, 500 and 630 Hz against
  the printed 40.0, 41.8, 44.4, 46.8 and 49.3 dB. Verified on PDF pages 28
  to 31 (printed pp. 22 to 25) of ISO 717-1:2020, and on PDF pages 22 to 24
  (printed pp. 14 to 16) of ISO 10140-5:2010+A1:2014.
- **Library behaviour:** publishes the table, not the figures.
  `building.LINING_REFERENCE_ELEMENTS` holds the 21 values of each column of
  Table E.1, checked band by band against a transcription of the page
  (conformance check "ISO 717-1:2020 Annex E, Table E.1", the 63 band values),
  and they reproduce every single number printed under each column, integer
  and to one decimal place. No change was required.
- **Status:** unreported.
